5) |
All students have submitted applications for admission. Some of the applications for admission have not been acted upon, therefore some more student will be accepted. The logic of which of the following is most similar to that of the argument above?
Answer: A
Explanation:
The Best Option is A
The question stem has theform:
All S and AP (All students are Applicants)
Some AP are AC (Some Applicants are accepted)
Some more S are AC. (Some more students are accepted)
Notice that (A) preserves very nicely the parallel in the conclusion because it uses the word ?more?. Thus, the error made in the stem argument (that some more students will be accepted) is preserved in (A): more apples will be loaded. (B) has a valid argument form (All S are J; X is an S; therefore, X is a J), so it is not parallel to the sample argument. (C) is not similar for that least two reasons. First, its conclusion is a recommendation (?should?), not a factual claim. Second, (C) uses one premise, not two premises as the sample argument does. (D) would have been parallel to the
sample argument onlyif the sample had the conclusion ?some more applications must be acted upon?. Finally choice (DE) choice (E) contains an argument that is fallacious but the fallacy is not similar to that of the question stem
|